| Both sides previous revisionPrevious revisionNext revision | Previous revision |
| mantisbt:plugins:emailreporting [2026/10/06 21:20] – [mail_engine] SL-Gundam | mantisbt:plugins:emailreporting [2026/10/12 15:57] (current) – [mail_engine] SL-Gundam |
|---|
| ^ Mail transport engine ^ State ^ IMAP ^ POP3 ^ Notes ^ | ^ Mail transport engine ^ State ^ IMAP ^ POP3 ^ Notes ^ |
| | PEAR (Net_IMAP and Net_POP3) | Working | Supported | Supported | These are the legacy mail transport packages. They are included by default | | | PEAR (Net_IMAP and Net_POP3) | Working | Supported | Supported | These are the legacy mail transport packages. They are included by default | |
| | [[https://packagist.org/packages/horde/imap_client|Horde/Imap_Client (Legacy and Modern)]] | Working (beta) | Supported | Supported | | | | [[https://packagist.org/packages/horde/imap_client|Horde/Imap_Client (Legacy and Modern)]] | Working (beta) | Supported | Supported | Horde Modern does not process attachments properly. Issue reported here: [[https://github.com/horde/Imap_Client/issues/54|#54]] | |
| | [[https://packagist.org/packages/javanile/php-imap2|Javanile/PHP-IMAP2]] | Removed | Supported | Not supported | Javanile/PHP-IMAP2 is migrating its code to use Webklex/PHP-IMAP. So would not be a good addition. | | | [[https://packagist.org/packages/javanile/php-imap2|Javanile/PHP-IMAP2]] | Removed | Supported | Not supported | Javanile/PHP-IMAP2 is migrating its code to use Webklex/PHP-IMAP. So would not be a good addition. | |
| | [[https://packagist.org/packages/webklex/php-imap|Webklex/PHP-IMAP]] | Working (beta) | Supported | Not supported | | | | [[https://packagist.org/packages/webklex/php-imap|Webklex/PHP-IMAP]] | Working (beta) | Supported | Not supported | | |
| |
| ^ Mail transport engine ^ Runtime in seconds ^ Peak Memory usage (real) ^ Notes ^ | ^ Mail transport engine ^ Runtime in seconds ^ Peak Memory usage (real) ^ Notes ^ |
| | PEAR (Net_IMAP and Net_POP3) | 3.6906 | 26.42 MiB (30 MiB) | Performs surprisingly well | | | PEAR (Net_IMAP) | 3.6906 | 26.42 MiB (30 MiB) | Performs surprisingly well | |
| | [[https://packagist.org/packages/horde/imap_client|Horde/Imap_Client (Legacy)]] | 3.3303 | 27.4 MiB (30 MiB) | Surprisingly close to PEAR | | | [[https://packagist.org/packages/horde/imap_client|Horde/Imap_Client (Legacy)]] | 3.3303 | 27.4 MiB (30 MiB) | Surprisingly close to PEAR | |
| | [[https://packagist.org/packages/horde/imap_client|Horde/Imap_Client (Modern)]] | 14.2741 | 42.3 MiB (46 MiB) | Only processed the first attachment in each email. This implementation needs further investigation | | | [[https://packagist.org/packages/horde/imap_client|Horde/Imap_Client (Modern)]] | 14.2741 | 42.3 MiB (46 MiB) | Only partially processed the first attachment in each email. Issue reported here: [[https://github.com/horde/Imap_Client/issues/54|#54]] | |
| | | [[https://packagist.org/packages/webklex/php-imap|Webklex/PHP-IMAP]] | 8.7441 (incomplete) | 89.06 MiB (120 MiB) | Crashed with error on the third email. "Fatal error: Allowed memory size of 134217728 bytes exhausted (tried to allocate 446464 bytes)". Implementation needs more work. | |
| | | [[https://packagist.org/packages/zetacomponents/mail|ZetaComponents/Mail]] | Unknown | Unknown | Zeta did everything correctly but crashed on cleanup. "SYSTEM WARNING 'dir(C:\WINDOWS\TEMP\20120-1/): Access is deni (code: 5)'". This needs to be investigated | |
| | | [[https://packagist.org/packages/directorytree/imapengine|DirectoryTree/ImapEngine]] | 3.4043 | 43.24 MiB (46 MiB) | A little more memory usage but otherwise performed well. There is potential for improvement on EmailReportings implementation | |
| | |
| | == Some performance numbers for EmailReporting 0.14.0 == |
| | |
| | ^ Mail transport engine ^ Runtime in seconds ^ Peak Memory usage (real) ^ Notes ^ |
| | | PEAR (Net_IMAP) | 3.6906 | 26.42 MiB (30 MiB) | Unchanged | |
| | | [[https://packagist.org/packages/horde/imap_client|Horde/Imap_Client (Legacy)]] | 3.3303 | 27.4 MiB (30 MiB) | Unchanged | |
| | | [[https://packagist.org/packages/horde/imap_client|Horde/Imap_Client (Modern)]] | 4.4009 | 26.67 MiB (34 MiB) | **Still has issues**. Performance numbers with Option 1 fix from [[https://github.com/horde/Imap_Client/issues/54|#54]] which is not included in 0.14.0 | |
| | [[https://packagist.org/packages/webklex/php-imap|Webklex/PHP-IMAP]] | 17.9368 | 31.09 MiB (42 MiB) | Implementation issues fixed for EmailReporting 0.14.0. Implementation could be better but at least the memory usage is not getting out of hand. | | | [[https://packagist.org/packages/webklex/php-imap|Webklex/PHP-IMAP]] | 17.9368 | 31.09 MiB (42 MiB) | Implementation issues fixed for EmailReporting 0.14.0. Implementation could be better but at least the memory usage is not getting out of hand. | |
| | [[https://packagist.org/packages/zetacomponents/mail|ZetaComponents/Mail]] | 3.5994 | 26.76 MiB (30 MiB) | Implementation issues fixed for EmailReporting 0.14.0 | | | [[https://packagist.org/packages/zetacomponents/mail|ZetaComponents/Mail]] | 3.5994 | 26.76 MiB (30 MiB) | Implementation issues fixed for EmailReporting 0.14.0 | |
| | [[https://packagist.org/packages/directorytree/imapengine|DirectoryTree/ImapEngine]] | 3.4043 | 43.24 MiB (46 MiB) | A little more memory usage compared to the others but otherwise performed well. There is potential for improvement on EmailReportings implementation | | | [[https://packagist.org/packages/directorytree/imapengine|DirectoryTree/ImapEngine]] | 3.3861 | 34.53 MiB (38 MiB) | Minor optimization for message retrieval | |
| |
| |
