View Issue Details

IDProjectCategoryView StatusLast Update
0009095mantisbtfeaturepublic2009-05-15 00:23
Reporterjoshr Assigned To 
PrioritynormalSeverityfeatureReproducibilityN/A
Status newResolutionopen 
Product Version1.1.1 
Summary0009095: Standardize use of Version and Build fields
Description

This is a feature request regarding adding a "Build" field, currently only found as the "Project Build" field when reporting an issue, to all places requesting a "Version" number.

I realize this issue already exists, but none of the found ones request the field in all cases, or quite like this issue.

I believe this field should be standardized across all locations. Any time you place a "Version" field of any type, it should have an accompianing "Build" field. In other words, "Product Version" has "Product Build" (as it currently does). "Fixed in Version" has "Fixed in Build". "Target Version" has "Target Build". etc.

I believe this will fix both the issues I'm personally having as well as prevent future "Please add a build field" mantis issues from appearing if a "Version" field is added to a new page.

Reasoning: The Build number is part of our version numbers: Major.Minor.Build. These numbers change every time we do a build (logically). Additionally, we track what items are fixed in each build. I'm running into issues where we have hundreds of version numbers for software (because of the build numbers) that's been tracked in our installation of Mantis for years. This makes the version list quite large.

Finally, I believe the Build number should be tracked as part of the Change Log (Fixed in Build), and possibly the Road Map (Target Build).

Additional Information

Finally, I want to say this is an excellent piece of software we've been using for years. We just recently upgraded to 1.1.1 from 1.0.5. Marvelous work, everyone.

TagsNo tags attached.

Activities

redjen

redjen

2008-04-21 16:30

reporter   ~0017644

I would love this feature as well.

mzdimal

mzdimal

2008-08-11 04:08

reporter   ~0019104

Definitely, this is a useful feature.

dhx

dhx

2009-04-02 01:59

reporter   ~0021367

How do you know the target build beforehand?

joshr

joshr

2009-05-15 00:23

reporter   ~0021825

Our builds are on a schedule, so we know what build number will be on what day. As part of scheduling, we can target a specific build.